Data as of Oct 28, 2026.
SIVR vs XLY: Differences, Returns & Fees
SIVR is a commodity fund and XLY an equity index fund, and over the year to Oct 28, 2026, SIVR returned +15.0% against −3.6%.
askIQ about this page
askIQ about SIVR and XLY
Net assets: $3.7bn on Oct 28, 2026 for abrdn Physical Silver Shares ETF, and $22.4bn on Oct 27, 2026 for State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF.
Pair scorecard
XLY costs 0.22 points a year less; their one-year returns differ by 18.6 points.
| Measure | SIVR | XLY |
|---|---|---|
| Return | ||
| Total return, 1 year | +15.0% | −3.6% |
| Drawdown | ||
| Below its high | 53.5%, high on Jan 28, 2026 | 6.8%, high on Jan 12, 2026 |
| Benchmark | ||
| What it tracks | Silver | Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index |
| Cost and size | ||
| Expense ratio | 0.30% | 0.08% |
| Net assets, SIVR as of Oct 28, 2026 and XLY as of Oct 27, 2026 | $3.7bn | $22.4bn |
| Holdings | ||
| Holdings in common | not published | |
| In the S&P 500, by weight | 100% | |
| Top ten holdings, share of the fund | 68.5% | |
Risk and return
Jul 31, 2009 to Oct 23, 2026 · 899 weekly returnsEach against its own benchmark: SIVR against SLV, Jul 31, 2009 to Oct 23, 2026; XLY against SPY, Dec 31, 1998 to Oct 23, 2026.
XLY returned more: +1,005.0% to +267.1%. XLY swung less: 19.7% to 31.0%. XLY fell less at its worst: −38.3% to −74.7%.
Full scorecard
19 measures, with how each is measured Open ↓
| Measure | SIVR | XLY | Edge | How it is measured |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return | ||||
| Total return | +267.1% | +1,005.0% | XLY | Price change plus distributions, reinvested. |
| Annualized | +7.8% | +14.9% | XLY | Total return as a yearly rate. |
| Price return | +267.1% | +795.1% | XLY | Price change alone, distributions left out. |
| Risk | ||||
| Volatility | 31.0% | 19.7% | XLY | Spread of weekly returns, annualized. Lower is steadier. |
| Downside deviation | 21.3% | 13.1% | XLY | Like volatility, counting only weeks below the Treasury bill rate. |
| Max drawdown | −74.7% | −38.3% | XLY | Deepest fall from a high to the low after it. |
| Upside capture | 99.6% | 118.0% | Share of its benchmark's rise caught in the weeks it rose. | |
| Downside capture | 99.8% | 106.8% | Share of its benchmark's fall taken in the weeks it fell. Lower is better. | |
| Beta | 1.00 | 1.10 | Not an edge | How far it moves for each 1% its benchmark moves. |
| R squared | 1.00 | 0.77 | Not an edge | Share of its weekly moves its benchmark explains. |
| Risk-adjusted | ||||
| Sharpe | 0.35 | 0.73 | XLY | Return above Treasury bills per unit of volatility. |
| Sortino | 0.51 | 1.09 | XLY | Return above Treasury bills per unit of downside deviation. |
| Treynor | 0.109 | 0.087 | Return above Treasury bills per unit of beta. | |
| Calmar | 0.10 | 0.39 | XLY | Annualized return divided by the max drawdown. |
| Against the benchmark | ||||
| Benchmark | SLV | SPY | The ETF each fund is measured against. | |
| Alpha | +0.2% a year | +0.7% a year | Not significant | Yearly return beyond what its beta to the benchmark predicts. |
| Alpha t-stat | 0.96 | 0.34 | Not an edge | How sure the alpha is. Below 2, it could be chance. |
| Alpha range | −0.2% to +0.6% | −3.2% to +4.6% | Includes zero | The 95% range for the yearly alpha. |
| Information ratio | 0.19 | 0.14 | Return against its benchmark per unit of tracking error. | |
| Tracking error | 0.8% | 10.6% | Not an edge | How far weekly returns stray from the benchmark, annualized. |
Computed by ETFIQ from Tiingo daily prices and ETFIQ's distribution records, 899 weekly returns. Cash rate: the 13-week Treasury bill.
Side by side
SIVR and XLY on the fields both publish, as of Oct 28, 2026. Source: ETFIQ.
SIVR and XLY do different jobs. What does each one do in a portfolio?
- What each follows. SIVR follows Silver and XLY follows Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index.
- One-year total return. Over 1 year to Oct 28, 2026 SIVR returned +15.0% and XLY −3.6% with distributions reinvested, a gap of 18.6 points.
- Cost. SIVR charges 0.30% of assets a year and XLY 0.08%, a gap of 0.22 points.
Data as of Oct 28, 2026.
The two-page PDF for this pair is coming. Save the comparison to follow its changes. Free. It needs an email sign-in, once.
Its expense ratio is 0.30% a year, for the three months to Jun 30, 2026, as its 10-Q states.
SIVR holds silver. Over the year to Oct 28, 2026 it returned +15.0% with distributions reinvested, against +14.9% for its benchmark, the price of silver. It sat 53.5% below its high of Jan 28, 2026 on Oct 28, 2026.
XLY
XLY tracks an index of Consumer discretionary. Over the year to Oct 28, 2026 it returned −3.6% with distributions reinvested, against +13.6% for its benchmark, the S&P 500 Index. The prospectus expense ratio is 0.08% a year. By its holdings published by its issuer for Oct 27, 2026, 100% of the fund by weight is stocks the S&P 500 also holds, across 48 positions, with the top ten at 68.5%. It sat 6.8% below its high of Jan 12, 2026 on Oct 28, 2026.
Questions people ask
- Which returned more over the last year, SIVR or XLY?
- In the year to Oct 28, 2026, with distributions reinvested, SIVR returned +15.0% and XLY −3.6%.
- Which is cheaper, SIVR or XLY?
- XLY is cheaper, by 0.22 percentage points a year. That is about $22 on $10,000 held for a year. Fees come from each fund's own filings.
Links are sources, not endorsements. A comparison is not a recommendation.
Cite this pageCitation, APA and Markdown
ETFIQ, SIVR against XLY, data as of Oct 28, 2026. https://etfiq.com/compare/any/sivr-vs-xly
ETFIQ. (Oct 28, 2026). SIVR against XLY. Retrieved from https://etfiq.com/compare/any/sivr-vs-xly
[SIVR against XLY (ETFIQ, Oct 28, 2026)](https://etfiq.com/compare/any/sivr-vs-xly)
Free to use with attribution for data ETFIQ computes; issuer data stays under its owner's terms.