Which returned more over the last year, VGIT or XLY?

In the year to Sep 12, 2026, with distributions reinvested, VGIT returned −1.2% and XLY returned −4.1%, so VGIT returned more. One year is one year; the longer windows are in the table.

Which is cheaper, VGIT or XLY?

VGIT charges 0.03% a year and XLY charges 0.08%, so VGIT is cheaper. Fees come from each fund's prospectus.

Data as of Sep 12, 2026. Both funds on the fields they both publish, from the same sources.

ETFIQetfiq.com · independent ETF data

VGIT vs XLY: how they differ

VGIT and XLY hold 0% of their weight in the same names, and VGIT returned more over the year.

Vanguard Intermediate-Term Treasury Index Fund and State Street(R) Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR(R) ETF.

What they hold in common

By the books each fund has filed, VGIT and XLY hold 0% of their money in the same securities at the same weight.

Largest positions each one holds and the other does not
Only in VGIT	Only in XLY
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.97%	Amazon.com Inc 22.24%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.94%	Tesla Inc 19.66%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.92%	Home Depot Inc/The 5.83%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.92%	McDonald's Corp 4.16%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.92%	TJX Cos Inc/The 3.93%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.89%	Booking Holdings Inc 3.44%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.89%	Lowe's Cos Inc 3.08%
United States Treasury Note/Bond 1.87%	Starbucks Corp 2.90%

Weight overlap is an ETFIQ calculation: for every security both funds hold, the smaller of the two weights, summed. Above 50%, holding both is close to holding one of them twice. Holdings dated Jun 30, 2026 and May 31, 2026.

VGIT and XLY on the fields both publish, as of Sep 12, 2026. Source: ETFIQ.
	VGIT Vanguard Intermediate-Term Treasury Index Fund	XLY State Street(R) Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR(R) ETF
Where it sits	Core index fund	Core index fund
Issuer	Vanguard	State Street
What it is	Intermediate-Term Treasury	Consumer discretionary
Total return, 1 year	−1.2%	−4.1%
S&P 500 over the same days	+17.5%	+17.5%
Gap to the S&P 500	−18.7 pts	−21.6 pts
Expense ratio	0.03%	0.08%
Holdings	103	47

VGIT in plain words

VGIT is a bond fund tracking the Intermediate-Term Treasury. Over the year to Sep 11, 2026 it returned −1.2% with distributions reinvested, against +17.5% for the S&P 500 and +23.0% for the Nasdaq-100. The prospectus expense ratio is 0.03% a year. It sat 3.7% below its high of Aug 4, 2020 on Sep 11, 2026.

XLY in plain words

XLY is an index equity fund tracking the Consumer discretionary. Over the year to Sep 11, 2026 it returned −4.1% with distributions reinvested, against +17.5% for the S&P 500 and +23.0% for the Nasdaq-100. The prospectus expense ratio is 0.08% a year. By its holdings filed for Jun 30, 2026, 100% of the fund by weight is stocks the S&P 500 also holds, across 47 positions, with the top ten at 69.2%. It sat 8.9% below its high of Jan 12, 2026 on Sep 11, 2026.

Questions people ask

Which returned more over the last year, VGIT or XLY?: In the year to Sep 12, 2026, with distributions reinvested, VGIT returned −1.2% and XLY returned −4.1%, so VGIT returned more. One year is one year; the longer windows are in the table.
Which is cheaper, VGIT or XLY?: VGIT charges 0.03% a year and XLY charges 0.08%, so VGIT is cheaper. Fees come from each fund's prospectus.

Other comparisons

Where to next

Where these figures came from

ETFIQ links to the documents behind every figure. It is not affiliated with any issuer, and a link is not an endorsement.

VGIT against XLY, ETFIQ, data as of Sep 12, 2026. Every figure is arithmetic on a named public source; the method is at etfiq.com/methodology. A comparison is not a recommendation.

Cite this page. ETFIQ, VGIT against XLY, data as of Sep 12, 2026. https://etfiq.com/compare/any/VGIT-XLY Free to use with attribution; the underlying files are at Open data.

A comparison is not a recommendation. Standards and sources